An introduction to the reformed doctrine of the two kingdoms. Over time calvins two kingdoms doctrine came to characterize the confessional reformed and presbyterian traditions, particularly after thomas cartwright used it to defend the autonomy of the church from the royal supremacy of the english queen elizabeth i. There are two kingdoms, one redemptive ruled by christ as redeemer, the other temporal ruled by christ or god as creator, sustainer. Speaking broadly, advocates of two kingdoms use it to place a greater emphasis on the spiritual authority of the church and discourage the church from engaging in the culture wars and politics of the civil realm. The two kingdoms and christian ethics jun 21 by reformed reader one of the worst misrepresentations of the reformation teaching of gods two kingdoms that ive heard goes like this.
Endorsements for those interested in a reformed two kingdom model, i can think of no better book to start than living in gods two kingdoms. But while calvin deployed two kingdoms language, he generally did so with somewhat different aims and his practical stance was more activistic. In both the sixteenth century and in contemporary reformed ecclesiology and political theology, there was a lot of controversy, and a lot of mutual misunderstanding, around the doctrine of the two kingdoms. But i was also coming to the conviction that the two kingdoms theme could provide very helpful insight into reformed thinking on natural law. For those interested in a reformed two kingdom model, i can think of no better book to start than living in gods two kingdoms. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read natural law and the two kingdoms. Whether you advocate for or against two kingdom theology, this book must be read prior to making any final determination as to the biblical and reformed. The church has fallen into the two kingdoms view, both consciously and unconsciously, and consequently has struggled with its role and message within the kingdom. Bearing sword in the state, turning cheek in the church. Reformed two kingdoms theology, differs fundamentally not just in the answers it yields to certain questions but even in the key questions it is seeking to answer. Sep 21, 2012 if luthers two kingdoms theology is what the escondido theology claims to follow, then its use of terms should be challenged, since it does not follow luther closely at all. Be the first to ask a question about living in gods two kingdoms. The faculty of westminster seminary, california, and especially david vandrunen, are well known for promoting the reformed two kingdoms r2k view. He argues that far too many christians confuse their calling in keeping the creation mandate with adams task in fulfilling that mandate before he fell into sin.
Kloostermans essay, natural law and the two kingdoms in the thought of herman bavinck seeks to explain bavincks position in light of recent criticisms. In several books, including the lost soul of american protestantism. The success of the gospel in samaria was not achieved without opposition. Cameron fraser currently serves as stated clerk of classis alberta south and saskatchewan of the christian reformed church, while engaging in various other ministries. Does two kingdoms theology make christians into republicans. Crouse t he recent emergence of two kingdoms and two cities approaches to christian social thinking is shown to have a keyand often unacknowledgedconnection to luthers reshaping of the augustinian paradigm. A study in the development of reformed social thought emory university studies in law and religion. Frame attributes this doctrine to luther, and he identifies the two kingdoms with church and state. But those kingdoms are very different from those of the r2k proponents. Conventional wisdom holds that the theology and social ethics of the reformed tradition stand at odds with concepts of natural law and the two kingdoms.
Power is a birthright of the people that the king borrows from. American academy of religion meeting, 2011, san francisco. His purpose in the spiritual realm is to make men christian and to hallow them in christ, and the instrument he uses to this end is only and always the word, and. In the various political theological debates that have raged across the reformed tradition over the centuries, virtually every group and every theologian has claimed the support of the legacy of john calvin. Scottish bulletin of evangelical theology 291 spring 2011 and natural law and which two kingdoms. To defend the summary of calvins two kingdoms doctrine. Unlike vandrunens other 2010 book, living in gods two kingdoms, which deliberately advocates for a two kingdoms worldview, natural law and the two kingdoms is a work of history which seeks principally to get the historical transcript right. Mapping theological traditions of church, culture, and civil order by robert c. Two kingdoms stand at our door each and every day of our lives. Basically, vandrunen demonstrates that the following ideas have been affirmed throughout reformed thought and prior. For those interested in a reformed twokingdom model, i can think of no better book to start than living in gods two kingdoms. A reformed twokingdoms interpretation of matthew 5.
These lectures were given at christ reformed churchs friday night academy from sept 20june 2014. Receive updates about all of our new books, videos, and special events. Reformed or radical twokingdoms r2k advocates have. A tale of two kingdoms by michael horton there is no better time to refresh our memories about the two kingdoms doctrine than at election time in the united states, when american protestantism often seems divided more by its political allegiances than its faith and practice. While this doctrine had its roots in the early protestant reformation, its most popular version today is associated with reformed theologians like. Mar 04, 2014 reformed two kingdoms advocates have spent a good deal of time trying to portray calvin as a keen disciple on luther on this issue. A study in the development of reformed social thought grand rapids. Two men, two kingdoms but there was a certain man called simon, who previously practiced sorcery in the city and astonished the people of samaria, claiming that he was someone great acts 8. Other critics have taken to calling it radical two kingdoms theology, in order to distinguish it from the original reformation doctrine.
Simply using the label two kingdoms or natural law does not mean you are speaking according to a reformed confessional understanding on the topic. I just finished reading the escondido theology by john frame, which is perhaps the strangest title for a book, ever. The two kingdoms and christian ethics the reformed reader. Barth rejected the covenant of works and the twofold mediatorship of christ to name just two reformed doctrines, and with them, natural law and two kingdoms. In addition, kloosterman speaks about his translations of two articles on the two kingdoms by s. This theology is associated with westminster theological seminary in california, with its most ardent defenders including david vandrunen and d. Over at the riddleblog, kim riddlebarger has made available eleven lectures interacting with the reformed understanding of the two kingdoms. A study in the development of reformed social thought ebook written by david vandrunen. Christians should view themselves as citizens of two distinct kingdoms the church and the world, and that efforts to transform society on the basis of christian principles are wrongheaded.
Sep 07, 2010 endorsements for those interested in a reformed twokingdom model, i can think of no better book to start than living in gods two kingdoms. Two kingdoms theology establishes a false dichotomy between the spiritual and worldly dimensions of life. Indeed, even contemporary advocates of the twentyfirst century reimagining of the two kingdoms as essentially church and state must at some points revert to calvins understanding if they wish to avoid conclusions they find disagreeable. But while calvin deployed two kingdoms language, he generally did so with somewhat different. There are two kingdoms, one redemptive ruled by christ as redeemer, the other temporal ruled by christ. Reformed or radical twokingdoms r2k advocates have spent a good deal of time trying to portray calvin as a keen disciple of luther on this issue. Frame is likewise mistaken when it comes to the doctrine of the two kingdoms, and this is the doctrine which appears in the subtitle of the book. Neoaugustinian liberalism and an eschatological two kingdoms. This is an important historical task for at least two reasons. This fact in itself warns against minimizing the importance of this doctrine for calvin, as well as against isolating it from his broader theology.
Lutheran and catholic neoconservatism and a paradoxical two kingdoms. Two kingdoms advocates, he believes, are cryptorepublicans. The two kingdoms exist side by side, both instituted directly by god for two different reasons. David vandrunens new book on the two kingdoms riddleblog. Aug 01, 2008 the language of two kingdoms, that of light and darkness, just seems to drip off the pages of the new testament. This book is a critical analysis of a theological movement john frame calls the escondido theology. How you think on this issue will affect how you interact with the culture around you. Two kingdoms the misadventures of captain headknowledge. This message is from the philadelphia conference on reformed theology 1994 event called the church at the end of the 21st century. Both call us to trustto put our hope for life and death in them. The subtitle of the book 1ca reformed response to two kingdom theology 1d gives the average consumer a gist of the content, and yet i still find it to be an absolutely awful title for a book. In recent years, the two kingdoms teaching of the reformed tradition has been a point of some contention. Chapter 5 the age of orthodoxy natural law and the two kingdoms in reformed doctrine and practice 149 chapter 6 theocratic new england, disestablished virginia.
To clarify one matter for readers who may be interested, i do not believe that augustines two cities refers to the same thing as the two kingdoms that i discuss in this book. Two kingdoms stand at our doorthe kingdom of god and the kingdom of man. First, theres a growing trend within reformed circles to adopt a neocalvinist or. A study in the development of reformed social thought. Reformed developments in two kingdoms doctrine 103 position of the divine right of kings, lex rex argued that, rather than the king being above the law, he was subject to it. That book is an extensive academic study of the historical development of reformed social thought with a particular focus on the reformed view of natural law and two kingdoms doctrine. Although initially skeptical, i have come to find it very useful when rightly understood as it usually is not. Two kingdom theology means that we only have to live as christians on sunday but not the rest of the week. A popular model of churchstate relations has arisen in the modern day known as the reformed two kingdoms r2k. For hooker, the spiritual kingdom is the internal forum, the union of the believer to christ through justification, and the forum of conscience over which christ himself exclusively rules. I have prayed for wise and courageous scholars to step upand step intothis fraternal debate within the reformed christian community concerning two kingdoms.
But while calvin deployed twokingdoms language, he generally did so with somewhat different aims and his practical stance was more activistic. A study in the development of reformed social thought eerdmans, 2010. The twokingdoms theology and christians today 2ktheology. Frame is distinctively christian and his response is clearly reformed. Chrysostom on two kingdoms what the reformed can learn from a 1532 synod part 1 calvin on the twofold kingdom calvin. Went through the book carefully in our adult ss class. Lutheran two kingdom theology is not escondido theology the blogosphere is full of discussions of two kingdom theology and neocalvinism. In early 2010, he published natural law and the two kingdoms. Niebuhr, bonhoeffer, and a dialectical two kingdoms. This volume challenges that conventional wisdom through a study of reformed social thought from the reformation to the present. These two kingdoms are as different, calvin says, as body and soul. What we see here is not a contest between two men for public acclaim but a battle between two kingdoms for the souls of the people.
This project focuses on the two competing positions rooted in the reformed tradition. Especially with the publication of david vandrunens living in gods two kingdoms, and john frames recent publication against socalled escondido theology, the reformed seem to all be talking about views. In this book, vandrunen shows that the reformations twokingdoms theology allows christians to faithfully navigate a course between, on the one hand, investing excessive hope in earthly government or, on the other, retreating from political life into isolationist enclaves. While the terminology may sound the same, it has had very different meanings in history, depending on the context and who is espousing it aquinas, luther, calvin, etc. Yesterday i tweeted a request to reformed bloggers in the know to post on the reformed side of american medical icon, the late dr. Reformed two kingdoms advocates have spent a good deal of time trying to portray calvin as a keen disciple on luther on this issue. Resources on the two kingdoms judging from the sorts of comments and criticisms i read it seems clear that a good number of people who are writing or commenting on the two kingoms or the two spheres ethic dont really understand it.
Nov 05, 2019 the reformed two kingdoms r2k scheme and its departure from the reformers. Nov 30, 2015 the two kingdoms theology and christians today 2ktheology. In his exposition of romans lloydjones deals with the tensions of life in two kingdoms as he addresses topics such as. One highly esteemed reformed scholar told me he is convinced that two kingdoms theology is on the rise because it gives christians an excuse to support the republican party despite its unchristian tendencies on poverty and race. For calvin, in contrast to both luther and the zwinglian branch of the reformation. The first introduced the two kingdoms doctrine while the third will explain the two kingdoms doctrine as it is taught in scripture. Two kingdoms come knocking christian reformed church. Vandrunen examines the idea of two kingdoms as it has existed in church history, especially in reformed theology. Sermons on the book of joshua pdf sermons on the book of judges pdf sermons on the book of james pdf. The theology divides the world into two separate spheres or realms one is the spiritual sphere kingdom of god where god rules, and the other is the worldly sphere where man rules. Natural law and two kingdoms in stereo the puritan board. Reformed developments in two kingdoms doctrine or two. The reformed two kingdoms approach advocates the civil magistrate upholding the first table of the law and, with that, the establishment of true religion. But there was a certain man called simon, who previously practiced sorcery in the city and astonished the people of samaria, claiming that he was someone great acts 8.
Professor of pastoral theology, reformed theological seminary. Apr 09, 2018 one highly esteemed reformed scholar told me he is convinced that two kingdoms theology is on the rise because it gives christians an excuse to support the republican party despite its unchristian tendencies on poverty and race. The key insight of this view is that it is to the church, and not any other institution, that christ committed the ministry of the word and sacraments. Ecclesiastical laws do not belong to the spiritual kingdom, but form part of the civil order. Neotwo kingdom theology is a radical departure from the position of the original reformed confessions. John calvin and the two kingdoms part 1 the calvinist. Natural law and the two kingdoms in dutch theology reformed. The second will describe john calvins two kingdoms doctrine while. A study in the development of reformed social thought emory university studies in law and religion vandrunen, david on. Littlejohn has written a good deal on this subject, especially natural law and the two kingdoms.
Both of them claim to offer us stability in the midst of uncertainty. Lutheran two kingdom theology is not escondido theology. Reformed developments in two kingdoms doctrine or two kingdoms doctrine in the reformed tradition j. Kingdoms apart is a strategic book because it compares and contrasts the onekingdom view and the two kingdoms view. Basically, the two kingdoms are the temporal littlejohn whose name, yes, is redolent of robin hood capably and clearly shows what luther, calvin, and hooker whom he continues to interpretrightly, i thinkas a magisterial reformer meant by the doctrine of the two kingdoms and then describes what the doctrine might mean for our. Reformed two kingdoms theology and a parallel two kingdoms. Reformed or radical two kingdoms r2k advocates have spent a good deal of time trying to portray calvin as a keen disciple of luther on this issue. Thats why what at first glance seems to be an insignificant vignette about a magician is actually of crucial importance.
In this book, vandrunen shows that the reformations twokingdoms theology allows christians to faithfully navigate a course between, on the one hand, investing. Most contemporary evangelicals seem to regard two kingdom theology as an exclusively lutheran doctrine, a view vandrunen labors at length to correct in his recent book natural law and the two kingdoms. Im amazed and disappointed at the negative reaction to the book in some reformed circles. The earlier book sought to determine whether two kingdoms theology is a legitimate strand within the reformed tradition. But the reformed view of the twokingdoms, as least according to the westminster standards, seems to go along the line of olevianus quotes above which you seemed to suggest isnt fully developed for some reason. Indeed, even contemporary advocates of the twentyfirst century reimagining of the two kingdoms as essentially church. Jan 05, 2017 these two kingdoms are as different, calvin says, as body and soul. Sep 03, 2012 in his more constructive theological work, living in gods two kingdoms, vandrunen offers a substantive exegetical argument for the two kingdoms doctrine.
Redemptivehistorical in scope, heavenly minded in emphasis, and gentle in tone, david vandrunen has made a great contribution to the ongoing discussion of the relationship of christianity and culture. The strength of this book is the overwhelming amount of historical evidence, judiciously analyzed and assessed, that positions the reformed tradition clearly in. Gods two kingdoms in two kingdoms gods david vandrunen a biblical vision for christianity and culture any christian perplexed by the bibles challenge to live as a dual citizen of gods eternal and temporal kingdoms will find vandrunens wise and charitable book an indispensable guide in sorting out the confused think. The reformed two kingdoms movements chief concerns, thena desire to reemphasize the centrality of the church in the christian life, a suspicion of overreaching claims for biblical authority and applicability, a healthy cynicism about the ability to realize gospel norms in temporal and political structures, a stress on the wide area of. Chapter 5 the age of orthodoxy natural law and the two kingdoms in reformed doctrine and practice 149 chapter 6 theocratic new england, disestablished virginia, and the spirituality of the church 212. For the better part of four centuries reformed thinkers widely affirmed doctrines of natural law and the two kingdoms and treated them as foundational concepts for their social thought. The place of the natural law and the two kingdoms doctrines in the development of reformed social thought is one of these aspects.
364 1117 972 150 396 583 153 261 17 131 583 1332 544 741 1244 531 1559 857 966 772 448 673 763 1213 605 423 323 841 599 83